Unlike a lot of the genres that were prominent during Hollywood’s golden era, I’m not sure Screwball Comedy is one that can be adapted to our modern times. Or at least, I’m not sure there’s been a film to come along that has convinced me otherwise. The Western, film noir, musicals, horror movies, and period epics have all resurfaced in one form or another as the decades of moviemaking have worn on. Though it’s hard to think of any recent films that effectively channel the irreverent wit and sophistication of the Screwball Comedy.
Even a movie like You’ve Got Mail, which was literally a remake of a screwball comedy, just feels like a cheesy Nora Ephron movie. Also, the Coen Brothers I’m sure have been influenced by films from this genre, but I have a hard time referring to Raising Arizona as a screwball comedy, as much as it tries. Now, I’m sure there’s some movie I’m forgetting, but honestly the only the thing that’s coming to mind that remotely conjures the tone of the romantic comedies of the ’30s and ’40s is Whit Stillman’s Metropolitan, but I suppose we’ll leave that for another Criterion Month entry. Continue reading →