in Movies, Shocktober

Buddy

If you’re a millennial, Casper Kelly may have been a bigger part of your childhood than you realize. We all know Too Many Cooks, the definitive Adult Swim infomercial. You might also know the Adult Swim show Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell and, if you’re cool (like me), Final Deployment 4: Queen Battle Walkthrough and Kelly’s two Adult Swim Yule Log films. But even before all that, Kelly was a key contributor to Cartoon Network in the late ’90s, arguably its peak.

Kelly wrote numerous bumpers for Cartoon Network back in the day. Remember when Fred Flintstone, Thundarr the Barbarian, and Chicken from Cow and Chicken fought over a parking spot? That was Kelly. For me, Kelly’s definitive work will always be The Scooby-Doo Project. First airing in segments on October 31, 1999, the special played out during commercial breaks of a Scooby-Doo marathon before being compiled into a complete special. Blending the animated characters with found-footage storytelling and live-action backgrounds gave the special a funny but also jarring feel and visual style. In a way, this special highlights what Kelly has always been best at, making something safe feel unsafe.

Casper Kelly’s work in feature films is a more recent development, as far as I can tell. I mentioned his feature-length Yule Log horror films for Adult Swim, but Kelly also contributed a memorable commercial for Panos Cosmatos’ Mandy (2018) and a segment to the 2025 anthology horror film V/H/S/Halloween. Given his background in television and his work with small budgets, I never would have guessed Kelly would get the opportunity to direct a film that would play in theaters. But here we are with Buddy, and I’m happy to report it’s gosh darn good.

Thanks to horror games like Five Nights at Freddy’s, there’s been a surge of horror films based around creepy children’s media over the past decade. There was The Banana Splits movie, Willy’s Wonderland, the two Five Nights at Freddy’s films, Mr. Crockett, Monkey’s Magic Merry-Go-Round, hell, we’ve even seen beloved children’s classics like Winnie-the-Pooh and Steamboat Willie turned into the Freddys and Jasons of today. Well, except for the fact that those particular films are absolute dogshit.

Buddy is the first one of these “spooky children’s media” projects I’ve liked, and I think a big part of that is Kelly’s experience with children’s programming. He even set Buddy in 1999, when he was very much active working for Cartoon Network. So if anyone is going to tackle Barney & Friends meets It, it’s Kelly.

The biggest question I had going into Buddy was, “What’s the format of this thing?” Kids’ shows are like 22 minutes long, but this film runs 96 minutes. Even ten minutes in, I was unsure. The film begins with a typical episode of Buddy. We see the opening credits, complete with a real earworm of a theme song. I see why they held sing-along screenings for this one. The show then proceeds like a Barney & Friends knockoff, with kids learning lessons alongside puppets, friendly adults, and Buddy, a life-size orange plush unicorn voiced by Keegan-Michael Key who loves to sing, dance, and kill people that try to break the formula of the show.

An episode of Buddy ends with Buddy and all the kids hugging and performing a saccharine sing-along. Then the show resets for a new episode, which follows the same pattern, ends, resets, etc. This is the first twenty minutes of the movie. But as we go on, the children start to realize they’re trapped, and the ones who rebel are killed by Buddy. The remaining kids escape into the surrounding wilderness, but Buddy pursues them so they can sing their song and reset the show all over again.

Halfway through, we leave the confines of Buddy’s show and enter the real world. Grace (Cristin Milioti) is a suburban mom of two on the verge of a nervous breakdown. Grace believes she used to have a third child, but no one remembers or believes her, not even her husband, Ben (Topher Grace). This whole sequence is muted in both look and tone. I love the writing here. Kelly and co-writer Jamie King’s dialogue is so understated. It’s never too clever nor too melodramatic. It’s realistic.

But Grace digs too deep and gets transported into Buddy’s world as a cast member on his show. Here, she discovers that her child, Freddy (Delaney Quinn), is a prisoner of Buddy. But Grace and the kids are ready to fight back, if they can figure out how to break the cycle.

The story is good. There are a few laughs, sad moments, scary moments and strong performances. The kids, in particular, handle the material with such poise. I was close to loving this movie until one scene shifted my opinion. The weird thing is, it’s a sequence I like. It takes place while the kids are trying to survive in the forest outside the confines of Buddy’s TV show. They encounter two other former kids’ show refugees: George (Clint Howard), a former child star still donning his prepubescent cowboy outfit, and Willie, a marionette puppet voiced by Michael Shannon, if you can believe it.

The idea of going so meta as to cast a real former child star like Clint Howard as a depraved, lunatic version of himself is hilarious. And yet, the scene is mildly amusing at best. It convinced me Buddy needs to either lean way harder into horror or way harder into comedy. This back-and-forth is nice, but I see so much more potential in going harder in either direction.

Still, as a longtime Adult Swim fan, I had a lot of fun with Buddy because, after all…

(To the tune of “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star”)

You love Buddy, yes you do;
And I love each one of you;
We’re together happily;
We’ll always be best buddies;
I love every one of you;
I’m so glad you love me too.

Write a Comment

Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.